New York: The NYC Irish Pub Crawl

In NYC to see the broadway show, Aladdin, we start our weekend at Heartland Brewery. After Visiting the Empire State Building, we stop at every Irish pub on the way to our Airbnb including McGee’s Pub, the famous How I Met Your Mother bar. 

As the residents of New York City flee to the coast for Memorial Day weekend, we take advantage of the empty sidewalks and open bar stools. Packing everything we need for the next two days into a backpack, we book an Airbnb and an early flight into LaGuardia Airport. Exiting the airport, we board the Jackson Heights Q70 bus, transfer to the metro, and for under $10 per person, we arrive in Herald’s Square. Strolling by bustling stores, food carts, boutiques, and restaurants, with no particular destination in mind, we see Heartland Brewery.

New York City.png
The menu is extensive with appetizers, rotisserie, desserts, daily specials, and eleven beers on tap. There are four hundred and fifty seats throughout the two story brewery in the Empire State Building, one of three locations.

After ordering a flight of beer and a giant pretzel, we notice a line forming around the brewery. Finishing our flight, we walk outside and follow the quickly moving line of people to the entrance of the Empire State Building. In only a few minutes we are through security, purchase a standard pass, and are on our way up to the eighty-sixth floor.

The eighty-sixth floor main deck, is the highest open-air observatory in New York. First opening in nineteen thirty-one, the Empire State Building was later granted their own zip code.


Descending back to ground level, we continue walking down the street. Waiting to cross at an intersection, a sign holder advertising The Long Hall catches our eye. Fans of Irish pubs, we decide to stop in for a beer.

New York City.png
Popular for viewing soccer games, this traditional Irish Pub offers GAA game specials and traditional Irish cuisine in addition to burgers, sandwiches, big plates, and appetizers.

After a pint of Guinness, we begin the walk to our Airbnb. Spotting an Irish flag a couple store fronts ahead, we have a brilliant idea to stop at every Irish pub on the way to our room. Let the Irish Pub Crawl begin!

New York City

New York City

2. Gabby O’Hara’s

3.  The PlayWright Irish Pub

4. Langan’s 

5. The Mean Fiddler

6. Hurley’s Saloon

7. P.J. Carney’s Pub

8. Molloy’s Irish Pub (now closed)

9. The Irish Pub

Extremely underestimating the quantity of Irish Pubs in New York City, we declare our challenge complete at pub number nine. Long after the sun has set, we check into our Airbnb and drop off our backpacks. We end our evening with a dinner of traditional Korean tabletop barbecue and makgeolli at Bann, the premier Korean restaurant in New York City for dinner.

New York City.png

Traveling Gingerbread Note: Since this visit to NYC we have eaten bulgogi and Korean barbecue in South Korea. We cannot wait to return to Bann to enjoy authentic Korean cuisine and makgeolli in the United States. We give this restaurant five stars!

The next morning after taking a walk through Central Park, we find another Irish pub and indulge in Irish coffees before watching Aladdin the Broadway Musical at the New Amsterdam Theatre.

New York City.png
The USS Maine National Monument, located in Central Park, was dedicated in nineteen thirteen to the men Killed in Havana Harbor aboard the USS Maine.
New York City.png
Originally built in nineteen thirteen, the New Amsterdam Theatre now only shows Disney performances. In Nineteen ninety-three the theatre closed for renovations after signing a ninety-nine year lease with Walt Disney. Four years later, the revamped Disney’s New Amsterdam Theatre premiered Hercules and the highest grossing musical of all time, The Lion King.

After a phenomenal show, we visit one last Irish pub, McGee’s, the bar that inspired How I Met Your Mother. We were disappointed in the dimly lit, sticky pub with little resemblance to the bar on How I Met Your Mother, MacLaren’s.

New York City.png

New York City.png
There are Monday food specials and a drink menu inspired by How I Met Your Mother such as: The Naked Man, S.O.B, Robin Sparkles, Don’t Drink Tequila, Daddy’s Home, The Pineapple Incident, Gay Pirate, Tantrum, Have you Met the Captain, and Slutty Pumpkin.
New York City
Jeff Koons unveiled his forty-five foot tall sculpture, Seated Ballerina, in the middle of Rockefeller Center. The inflatable, nylon sculpture represents his modern interpretation of the Roman Mythology Goddess, Venus.

Not sure how we even found the narrow staircase entering what we thought was a Japanese restaurant, we enter Yuki 55, a Japanese karaoke bar. NYC.png

Attracting attention of the staff being the only two occupants, we decide to stay for one quick drink after realizing our mistake. As we are about to pay our bill, customers trickle into the narrow bar, popular American music fills the air, inner Japanese and American Idols are released, and we spend the remainder of our evening in the small, magical, sake filled bar.

May 2017


Author: The Traveling Gingerbread

My fiancé, Mitch, and I have been traveling together over four years. Living and working full time in Pittsburgh, PA, we travel as much as our vacation days and finances allow. Each adventure is packed with activities, tours, and experiences to maximize our time. As craft beer lovers, we always try to fit in a visit to a local brewery. 
In Tokyo, we laughed every time we saw someone talking on their large, animated phone case. We had to buy one. Having an obsolete IPhone 5, the selection was limited. We purchased Gingy off a neglected rack in Shinjuku, Tokyo and The Traveling Gingerbread was born. You can purchase your own adorable gingerbread friend here! 
The Traveling Gingerbread is an entertaining account of our travels, fun facts, and tips we learned along the way.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s